14 Comments
Michael
12/11/2019 11:52:31 am
No because if it was a cat they would not have found it under the bed and in the start it would have been impossible to catch it and cats have nails they can scratch you dogs don't.And if it was a hamster you would not find it and also you can't catch it it small it can go through little holes.So that's why i think that story does not work with another animal.
Reply
Raven B
12/11/2019 11:56:59 am
Dogs don't scratch, they bite you sometimes...
Reply
Raven B
12/11/2019 11:54:39 am
I think this story would have worked with a cat. I say this because, cats and dogs aren't that different from each other. Cats, dogs, horses, SAME THING! Cats have fears, cats can run away from home.(Like my cat does!) The author just chose a dog because she don't have a dog around her for along time. OH, and for your information....CATS ARE WAY BETTER THAN DOGS! It's not an opinion, it's a fact! SO, if you're getting a new pet for Christmas, pray to God you get a cat. NO DOGS! But, yes. I do think this story would worked with a cat.(THIS IS MY OPINION, SO DON'T GET MAD AT ME!)
Reply
joseph
12/11/2019 11:59:29 am
I agree with cats have alot of fears.
Reply
Jaslene
12/11/2019 11:59:38 am
I feel dogs are better
Reply
Jaslene
12/11/2019 11:57:02 am
If Winn-Dixie was not a dog in the story I think it would have been different. I say this because If a cat was afraid of a thunder storm and would have been outside the cat would ran away. The cat or any other animal would have not cared as much for Opal as much as Winn-Dixie .That is why I think the story would have been different if Winn- Dixie was another animal.
Reply
Joseph
12/11/2019 11:57:43 am
In my opinion it would have not worked out because if it would have been cat or anything else Sweetie Pie would have not liked a cat.It said in the book that she had not had a DOG in a long time that she wanted one really bad.Also if the thunder storm would have been there a cat would have not been scared of it and would just stay asleep or what ever it was doing. ;)
Reply
Misael
12/11/2019 11:59:05 am
No, I don't think that it might've worked with another type of animal, like a cat, or a bunny, or a turtle. Okay, I don't know what I'm saying. Opal loves dogs, even though the preacher doesn't let her get one. When Opal found a dog, and when she asked the preacher if she can keep it. He said no, and then Opal said this dog needs H E R. I think that was just one of her things where she would try to beg harder. With a cat, she would've be like "Meh, I can keep it for a few months." I don't even think she might keep a turtle. I think the story would only work with a D O G!
Reply
Clayton
12/11/2019 11:59:30 am
NO!! I don't think it would have worked with a different type of animal. The first reason why I say this is because cat aren't as exciting as dog, there also not as fun to play with. Also I don't think Winn-Dixie would have had the same traits as he does in the book. Also, I say this because he wouldn't be such a loving character. I can't think of a animal that can beat a dog for the role as Winn-Dixie. I have a really strong opinion about this so, I have to go with my gut on this one. Can you think of a animal that could play the role of Winn-Dixie? I honestly don't think so. I think 100% that no animal can beat a dog for the role of Winn-Dixie. What about you and explain why.
Reply
Christopher
12/11/2019 11:59:33 am
I would rather work with cats because I had a cat before in our aparment and it didn't really do anything so I took care of it. Although it might of not worked if the cat wasn't calm.So it a yes and no.:)
Reply
Nicholas
12/11/2019 11:59:39 am
I think no because she wouldn't have miss Franny Block as a friend, Sweetie Pie, Gloria, and the bald headed babies. She wouldn't have friends and the book wouldn't be made or get a 1 star review. People would infer a different animal it would probably be a dog because dogs could almost be a bear like in a book, no other animal could be a bear except for a bear. That's my opinon.
Reply
Melanie avalos
12/11/2019 11:59:55 am
I don't really think the story wouldn't have work with other animals because a cat is not real calm, and if its tiger, bird, snake, rabbit, or other animal. But, Winn-Dixie is a nice dog that I would like to have. I don't think, that's my opinion.
Reply
Noah
12/12/2019 11:48:26 am
I know that Winn-Dixie is a dog but i dont think that another animal would have done well because it was a dog and dogs are easy to catch cats ehh... not really. The reason I say this is because cats get constiantly scared easily and when they get scared they just jump up and scratch anything that comes in their way and destroys everything in your house so it really would'nt work with another animal.
Reply
Maria
12/16/2019 06:39:41 pm
I don't think a cat or another animal will work.I say this because cats don't be running to other peoples back yard because their usually in the house sleeping all day long.Dogs they like to run and play around.That means Opal would have never been friends with Gloria,Miss Franny,and Amanda.She wouldn't have even known who Gloria and Miss Franny is.Also when the cat would have been running around the supermarket and jumped on the manager the cat what have scratched the managers face then he could've cried like he did with Winn-Dixie.Also cats aren't calm they are more,..crazy.So that's why I think it won't work with another animal.
Reply
Your comment will be posted after it is approved.
Leave a Reply. |
Mr. CabreraThis blog is for the Class of 2020, room 24. Remember, show great Digital Citizenship. Archives
May 2020
Categories |